Local Thrift Stores Are a Better Alternative to Fast Fashion


 By Annie Renz 

Stonehill College Sophomore Maddy Raspen started thrifting years ago with her mother. What started out as her mother’s knack for finding collectable bowls turned into Raspen’s current passion for finding name brand clothes at cheap prices.

“It’s bang for your buck,” said Raspen.

A growing number of people are turning to thrifting as an alternative to so-called “fast fashion,” a term used for mass-production of low-cost clothing to meet the latest trends.

A major catalyst for the current movement away from fast fashion is the detrimental impact that fast fashion has on the environment.

According to Earth.org, 20% of global wastewater comes from textile dying and 93 billion cubic meters of water are contaminated by toxic chemicals.

Air pollution is another major issue that fast fashion causes, the group said.

Earth.org said the fast fashion industry accounts for 10% of global pollution, making it the second-largest industrial polluter.

An evolving issue with fast fashion is that as clothing production increases, garment usage lifetime decreases.

Between the years 2000 and 2015, Earth.org reports that clothing sales doubled even though the number of times an item was worn decreased by 36%.

Raspen said the limited lifespan of a fast fashion item is a major factor as to why she doesn’t wear that kind of clothing.

“The downside to fast fashion would be the clothes are cheaply made so you don’t have it forever. You would get one wear out of a SHEIN shirt, and it’s done for,” she said.

“A typical price for a shirt at Forever 21 is 10 bucks, and it’s bad for the environment. It’s made out of crap. For 10 bucks I could get five different shirts at Salvation Army or at a thrift store,” said Raspen.

The Salvation Army is similar to a thrift store and is an eco-friendlier option with higher quality clothing compared to fast fashion outlets, some say.

The Salvation Army in Brockton, Massachusetts is a one-stop shop for cheap clothing, furniture, and home goods. Endless racks of clothing take up the majority of the store’s interior, thanks to the 3000 pieces of donated clothing the location receives every day.

This store is not your typical thrift store; while some shoppers come in to find good “steals” for name brand hidden gems, the Salvation Army also provides for people living off very little.

There are a few differences between the Salvation Army and other thrift stores.

“We are a non-profit, that’s the biggest difference here,” said Dave Halter, the store manager at Salvation Army Brockton. “Most thrift stores try to make some money, or you have consignment that pays the person. All our stuff is donated, maybe a thrift store owner buys stuff to sell for good money.”

The Salvation Army caters to the needs of all people.

“That’s what Salvation Army offers that fast fashion cannot: if somebody walks in here and has no money, I can tell them another place to go, Salvation Army Church,” said Halter.

Salvation Army Church is separate from the main locations of Salvation Army and provides vouchers to those in desperate need. With a voucher, a customer can get clothing and household goods for free.

“We see it all,” said Halter. “People steal a lot. I caught a guy stealing once and he was on edge, but once I started talking to him about our church, he was agreeable.”

Halter said shopping at Salvation Army is a better alternative to fast fashion because of the large array of styles and options a shopper will find.

“I was a shopper [at Salvation Army] for about ten years before working here because of the eclectic choices offered. The stuff I would find here wouldn’t be at a store just walking around,” said Halter.

But, if name brand, fast fashion-esque apparel is what a shopper is after, they can find those items at Salvation Army for cheaper prices.

“We’ve had donations from fast fashion. We had a Zara station for two months. Zara donated all returns and damages to Salvation Army, and a lot of that stuff was usually fine,” said Halter.

Consignment is another alternative to fast fashion where goods are left in the possession of another party to sell.

Janet’s Consignments is just a two-minute drive from Stonehill College and sells everything from shoes and coats to ice skates. The small interior is filled floor to ceiling with items, making it easily possible for shoppers to find exactly what they are looking for.

Pat Hite is the current owner of Janet’s Consignments and has been for the past nine years. She is the third owner of the store’s 45-year operation.

“Our customers are any age from young adult to senior citizens. We have a broad range of women’s attire and are currently building our men’s side which would also have the same demographic,” said Hite.

Hite said she looks for only gently worn items with high quality.

“We don’t take Walmart stuff… people come here for high quality bargain prices. People will find jewelry or designer bags here and come back saying how many compliments they receive,” said Hite.

At Janet’s Consignments, donors and the store share sales.

“This is a partnership,” said Hite. “People can come in with goods and the consigner gets 50%, we get 50%. We are about recycling and “go-green”, we are about someone’s trash is another man’s treasure.”

Like Salvation Army, fast fashion clothing can also be found at Janet’s Consignments.

“People can find [fast fashion] items here at a lower cost and make money for their own. We feature that on our webpage: “Posh-Consignments” to feature our posh items,” said Hite.

Another reason why Hite said shopping at a place like Janet’s is a better alternative to fast fashion is the higher possibility of finding different styles or trends of clothing.

“People find unique items that they wouldn’t find at Macys, for example. We offer different brands, artistic items, one-of-a-kind items,” Hite said.

Along with Raspen, Alina St. George is another Stonehill student and avid “thrifter”. Like Raspen, St. George was introduced to thrifting at a young age and has carried that interest with her into college.

“My mom has been taking me to cute little consignment boutiques and shops for my entire life… my older sister, [Cadence Denniston], she’s the one who got me into going to Salvation Army, Goodwill bins, and things like that. She will stay at the Goodwill bins for five hours, she gets the best stuff,” said St. George.

Both students said one of the reasons why they thrift is to find those unique items that can’t be found at a mall.

“When you go to a mall, you want to go into the name brand stores, you don’t necessarily think about the other stores. When you go thrifting you have no choice, there is a huge variety of brands and different items and styles,” said St. George.

“There’s literally endless options,” said Raspen. “You can find cool stuff and be different from everyone else.”

Being college students, Raspen and St. George said a benefit to thrifting is the cheap costs with low stakes.

“It’s definitely a big money saver,” said St. George. “You pay so much for the brand when you go to their stores, like lululemon, it’s ridiculously expensive. And for what? Instead of buying them full price, even though sometimes I do, I can go to a thrift store and those items are cheaper.”

Raspen agreed, “And durability, they’re made to last. It’s older clothes, so it’s that good quality stuff. It doesn’t hurt to buy from a thrift store, if it doesn’t fit, you can always donate it back.”

Ultimately, it is the eco-friendly aspect of thrift stores that draws St. George to the stores.

“Goodwill and those kinds of stores create a place to give clothes that you don’t want to wear anymore. If someone doesn’t want to wear it anymore or if they don’t need it anymore, the clothes aren’t just going in the trash. I think that’s good for waste purposes,” said St. George.

Both students recognize the detrimental harm that fast fashion has on the environment.

“You’re dealing with something ethically questionable,” said St. George. “With fast fashion, there are things that are made without the environment in mind and often in sweatshops. It’s not ecofriendly or friendly to humans. It’s not good for anybody and the material sucks.”

“With thrifting, when you buy from their stores, the money is also going somewhere because some stores help charities. When you buy from fast fashion, you are just giving right back to a corporation and probably to sweatshops,” said Raspen.


Comments